Originally Posted by
Smokey Bear
Same cars and situation as you and was with liberty also. They were wankers to deal with, I left them in the end but I did get insured on my 530d But when renewing came around 123.ie were cheaper by a grand. Beats me how they can justify it and they got a bit tongue tied on the phone when I told them that I was previously insured on this exact 530d for nearly 3 years before I bought the m3. They still wanted the logbook and in the end I told them no that I want to be insured immediately and they need to check their records and then justify the fact that I couldn't be insured at 27 on a car I was previously insured on for a number of years at 23.
I think after all the hassle I've had with insurance wouldn't encourage me to be leniant with settling in the event of an accident, I can see why the "claim culture" has gotten out of hand, loyalty and honesty isn't rewarded.