E46 Rear lip, opinions.

[John_D]

Well as the title says, what do you think of them?
I currently have one (ebay rep) and am contemplating removing it for a cleaner look.

[Gar]

Yes from me I like them finishs off the end of the car nicely

[RobM]

The lip spoiler on the bootlid ? ?

Im a bit biased but Yeah I really like them I think cars without them look unfinished.

[John_D]

Yeah sorry Rob should have been more clear, the boot lip spoiler.

[Leins]

Yep, I've always liked them on the E46

[GerH]

I think they look well. I put one on mine and very happy with how it turned out

[RobM]

Yeah sorry Rob should have been more clear, the boot lip spoiler.

Ah yeah man defo. It's a no brainer ye won't regret it

Edit.
I'm only getting now that its not a genuine one.

Is it much different?
Can you post a picture ?

[John_D]

Don't have one to hand but the genuine one is a bit more rounded as opposed to the sharp edge features of the reps.

[Chrispyfish]

Don't have one to hand but the genuine one is a bit more rounded as opposed to the sharp edge features of the reps.

I voted for OEM John, doing a car at the minute with a ebay jobbie and the size and cut isn't great, the OEM ones are much better fir for obvious reasons

[John_D]

Don't have one to hand but the genuine one is a bit more rounded as opposed to the sharp edge features of the reps.

I voted for OEM John, doing a car at the minute with a ebay jobbie and the size and cut isn't great, the OEM ones are much better fir for obvious reasons

Cheers I presume the oem one is more rigid and pre-bent? The eBay hobbies are flexible and can be messy to get looking 100%