e30 M3 V e46 M3

[Leins]

Btw the poll is not showing up on tapatalk.
A lot more people have posted than voted so I presume it because vote can't be seen on tapatalk

As Gar said, I don't think polls have ever been supported on Tapatalk from what I can gather, for whatever reason

The hilarious thing seems to be that there are quite a few forums out there I've just seen who ran a poll about whether or not to keep Tapatalk, and none of the Tapatalk users could vote

[michael320]

Ive always liked the E30 M3 but it would be more of a vanity thing for me, mainly because of its rarity and appeal, Ive never driven one so I couldn't really say too much but I'd imagine the performance wouldn't blow you away... maybe it makes up for it in driving enjoyment but for going out for a hard blast in something with a bit of oomph it would have to be the E46...

All that said if the two sets of keys were left in front of me I'd probably have the E30.

[tom]

have both currently, the e30 just 8 years, the e46 3 years, i had a csl before the ordinary m3 for a spell also, regardless of the value of either id go with the e46, its a nicer place to be the 6 cylinder is brilliant, to get from 1 into the other you,d know there related even with the 13 year age gap

[narusa]

Ok my personal opinion on both of these,in standard trim,by the looks and performance marginaly it has to be e46,modified 200% e46. Couple years ago i did a project with e30M3 fitting s54 engine,drove it afterwards-and to be honest i wasn't impressed at all. It still drives like an old car,stops like an old car,and inside feels like an old car,but its not bad,for my liking its not old enough

[rebel.ranter]

To stick in a garage as an investment & to look at it would be the e30. But the e46 would probably be a better all round driver in the real world for everyday driving. So it depends in whether the question is investment reasons or driving reasons. I think the newer car will always be a nicer place. Nostalgia & deck chair viewing the e30 wins.